What did I like about this class? I liked it for the reason I signed up to take it: It was a wonderful opportunity to learn about a topic that never really gets mentioned elsewhere, and really a topic which is something that so few people know anything about. I enjoyed learning about the giant beavers, the quirky French dialects, and all the other tidbits of culture and history of that quasi-mythical land called Canada. I liked the fact that I finally learned how Canada went from French to British. I liked the self discovery aspect covered by the blogs, forcing me to look for what I might otherwise consider impossible to find(as if I could have even considered Canadian history at all to be possible before this class). Oh, and random ranting, random ranting is always fun to listen to. And the definitive near lack of anything mathematics related, I liked that. Very much.
What didn't I like? Politics. For having such a dysfunctional government, there was so much focus on politics, after a while it was like that was the only thing that ever happened in Canada, bad boring politics. I mean, I know there isn't
that much to Canada, but still, even hearing about some guy's life in the middle of nowhere is better than politics. Oh and the 5 books we got for the class, we only really used 3 of them (I say that like a bad thing... Honestly some of those books are
really boring. I'd rethink how much depth the class gets into, and revise the literature for the class. For a two semester class, perhaps the Thorner books are more useful, as there is more time to analyze their depth, but the pace was so fast, we just never got to them. (Though I wish we had gotten to 'Fire and Ice', it seemed like a really insightful book, if not from a historical perspective than a sociological view.)).
What would I change? Hmmmm... I guess the main thing I would try and do is make the class more Civ-ish. In the Civ classes, we spent a fair amount of time going over the literature of the age of study. In our class, we mentioned several notable authors, but seeing what they had written would have been insightful(especially considering that most of them wrote about life in Canada). What else... A bit of Geography in the beginning would have been really nice (it is such a massive influence on society, especially in earlier history). I realize that some politics is necessary, but a little more tie into its effect on society would be nice. More movie nights would be nice (early reruns of 'Hockey Night in Canada' anyone?), as would more pictures (I'm still waiting to see this fabled giant beaver!).
And just for the record, I have to agree with my classmates that:
A) Prof. Ruane is an awesome teacher
B) Lots of notes/names/dates/places suck
C) Maps and pictures are helpful
D) The last 100 or so years are way more interesting than the 300 before them (but the 10000 before that are still ok)
What else can I say? I don't know... It was an interesting class, not the best, but definitely not the worst. With some improvements, this could easily be a very promising class. Especially for an inherently boring topic like the history of Canada. I mean, its Canada for cripes sake, nothing
ever happens in Canada!
...Right?